Sponge Eyeballs!

Description: 
 
I especially recommend this "eye-catching" prop for anyone looking to grab someone's eye with something novel. -Jeff McBride, MyLovelyAssistant

Full Review
Are you ready for some unusual, bizarre sponge magic?
If you are looking for something different, something strange, then sponge eyeballs are for you. Close up horror themed magic for your upcoming Halloween show or your next children party. 

Perfect for an alternative cups and eyeballs routine. Use them for jokes and gags. Put a fork into your eye and (pretend) pluck out an eyeball, if you are into that sort of things. The set comes with four sponge eyeballs without instructions